Vegan Baked Mac and Cheese (The Big Cheese)

Jump to Recipe

This Easter morning, I hesitated to make this Vegan Baked Mac and Cheese. My son loves mac and cheese — but he’s never had it baked like this. Still, I wanted to try. So when it was time to slide it into the oven, toppings and all, I went for it — and made sure he was right there to watch.

Because once we believe there’s only one way something should be done, we leave no room for anything new.

Something Old, Something New

My son is very familiar with mac and cheese; it’s one of his favorite foods, right there behind pizza.

There are three versions he likes:

• The boxed kind — specifically Annie’s Vegan Mac
• The frozen kind — Amy’s Vegan Rice Mac & Cheeze
• And the homemade stovetop version — the one I make with my cashew cheese sauce

All of them are familiar. All of them are safe. And today, all of them stayed on the shelf to make room for something new.

• This one is baked
• The texture is different
• There’s a top layer

My son had to make room for this in his neurodivergent head, which often tells him he can only eat what he’s eaten before. But something shifts when he’s in the kitchen with me, watching it happen. Watching it change.

Eyes Wide Open

He watched everything:

• Me whisking the sauce
• Pouring it over the pasta
• Spooning it into the casserole dish

And I talked to him the whole time — not to convince him, just to show him:

• What was the same
• What was different

Then when I made the topping — hemp seeds, nutritional yeast, and breadcrumbs pulsed together into something like grated parmesan — I could tell by his wide eyes that he had questions.

So before I sprinkled the dairy-free grated parmesan over the casserole dish I offered an explanation.

I told him that sometimes, like on Easter, mac and cheese isn’t just made on the stove. It’s baked with a topping, making it a little more special — a special holiday dish.

At the Kids Table

Because he watched and listened, once dinner hit the table there were no:

• Questions
• Comments
• Second-guessing
• Funny looks

He sat down, took a bite, and kept going until there was nothing left on his plate — which was loaded with green beans made with hollandaise sauce, maple-glazed sweet potatoes, and a vegan ham by Tofurky.

Kitchen Help, For Parents

If your child isn’t helping, they’re still learning. Even just being in the kitchen matters — watching, listening, and noticing. You don’t have to turn it into a lesson. You don’t have to convince them to try anything. Just talk.

• Point out what’s the same
• Name what’s different
• Make small connections to foods they already know

Say things like:

• “This is like the mac and cheese you like — just baked”
• “This part is new, but the flavor might feel familiar”

That’s how something new starts to feel less new. Not because they were told to try it — but because they had time to see it, hear it, and understand it. That’s the Messy Plate Method in real time — in the kitchen.

Messy Little Readers Library

The Big Cheese by Jory John

The Story & Recipe Pairing

The Big Cheese is a story about confidence, comparison, and what it looks like when something doesn’t go the way you thought it would.

Making this Vegan Baked Mac and Cheese creates a similar moment in the kitchen. Mac and cheese — from a box — is something most kids know. They know what it looks like, feels like, and tastes like. But this one is baked, and the outcome can be unexpected.

In The Big Cheese, things don’t go the way he expects either — and he has to figure out what to do with that.

Best For:

All ages are welcome, but it’s typically best suited for ages 3-8, especially children who are starting to notice how things are “supposed” to be.

Read Along Focus:

Encourage kids to notice how the Big Cheese sees himself — and how that changes over time. Then connect that to the kitchen — this mac and cheese may look different from what they expect, but that doesn’t mean it won’t still be good.

Things to Point Out While Reading:

• The Big Cheese believes he is the best at everything
• He struggles when something challenges that idea
• He learns that there are other ways to be good
• Something different doesn’t mean something is wrong

Simple Lessons (No Lecturing):

• There isn’t just one “right” way for something to be good
• Something can be different and still be enjoyable
• Familiar foods can change and still feel safe

Kitchen Tie-In:

While making the mac and cheese:

• Point out what looks familiar (pasta, creamy sauce)
• Notice what’s different (baking, the topping, the texture)
• Talk about how the dish changes in the oven
• Let them watch the transformation from stovetop to baked

You can say:

• “This looks like mac and cheese — just made a different way”
• “Some parts are the same, and some parts are new”
• “We’re just trying something a little different today”

The Moment You’re Creating

A whisk moving through a creamy sauce, pasta being folded in, and a casserole dish sliding into the oven — something familiar baked into something new. And when they sit down to eat, it’s still mac and cheese. Cheese on the bottom, in the middle, even on the top — until it’s gone, because they ate every bite.

This is the “Big Cheese” moment every parent hopes for, especially on a holiday like Easter.

This post contains affiliate links. I may earn compensation when you click on the links at no additional cost to you.