Overflowing Vegan Apple Pie (Kid-Made)

Jump to Recipe

Every fall our family goes apple picking — and every fall we pick far more apples than we planned. For years the solution has been this Overflowing Vegan Apple Pie, piled high with cinnamon apples and baked until the filling spills over the crust. But the real reason this pie matters isn’t the apples. It’s that my son makes it. And when kids help build something from the ground up, it changes how they see it later when it shows up on the plate.

Let Them Build Their Mountain

If you want kids to feel comfortable with a food, let them build it.

With this pie, that might look like:

• Peeling apples
• Slicing them (uneven counts)
• Tossing them in cinnamon and sugar
• Stacking them higher and higher into the crust

A few things might happen when you let them take over:

• The pile might start leaning
• The apples might spill over the edge
• At some point the pie might become ridiculously full

That’s usually a good sign you’re doing it right.

Small Decisions, Big Pie

Another way to build ownership is to let kids make small choices while the pie comes together.

Things like:

• Deciding how thin to slice the apples
• Tasting the filling and deciding if it needs more cinnamon
• Choosing how high the apples should be stacked
• Deciding if the pie needs “just one more apple”

These tiny decisions matter more than they seem. Because when kids help decide how a recipe turns out, the food stops feeling like something that appeared on their plate.

It becomes something they helped build from the ground up.

The Holiday Takeover

My son brings his pie to every Thanksgiving and Christmas celebration. Holiday meals can be overwhelming for kids in ways we don’t always notice right away.

• New foods
• Different textures
• People watching them eat
• Comments like, “Just try one bite”

Even foods they normally love can suddenly feel like too much when they show up in a different form on a louder-than-usual day with expectations attached. But when a child brings something to the table that they made themselves, the entire dynamic changes.

This isn’t a new food they’re being encouraged to try. It’s:

• Something they contributed
• Something they recognize from beginning to end
• Something they experienced — from picking and peeling to slicing, stirring, tasting, and deciding
  

That ownership shows up later at the table in ways no amount of prompting ever could.

That’s the heart of the Messy Plate Method — when kids help build the food, it no longer feels unfamiliar when it shows up on their plate.

Messy Little Readers Library

Ten Apples Up On Top! by Dr. Seuss

The Story & Recipe Pairing

Ten Apples Up On Top! is a playful story about animals stacking apples higher and higher, balancing them carefully while trying not to let the whole tower topple over.

Making this Overflowing Vegan Apple Pie offers a similar kind of fun in the kitchen, where apples are peeled, sliced, tossed with cinnamon and sugar, and stacked higher and higher into the crust.

Just like in the book, the goal isn’t perfection.

It’s seeing how high the apples can go before gravity wins.

Best For:

All ages are welcome, but it’s typically best suited for ages 2–6, especially children who enjoy silly counting books and playful challenges.

Read Along Focus:

Encourage kids to notice how the characters keep stacking apples higher and higher, even when the pile starts to wobble.

Sometimes the fun is seeing how far something can go before it tips over.

Things to Point Out While Reading:

• Apples can be stacked higher and higher
• Balancing takes practice
• Sometimes things get a little wobbly before they fall

Simple Lessons (No Lecturing):

• Trying something new doesn’t have to be perfect
• Learning happens through experimenting
• Sometimes the best part is the process, not the outcome

Kitchen Tie-In:

While making the pie:

• Let kids slice the apples and notice how different the shapes look
• Toss the slices in cinnamon and sugar and watch them change color
• Stack the apples into the crust just like the characters stack apples in the book
• See how high the pile can go before the pie becomes wonderfully overflowing

The Moment You’re Creating

Apple slices piling higher and higher into the crust, cinnamon filling the kitchen with the smell of fall, and small hands carefully stacking just one more layer.

By the time the pie goes into the oven, the mountain of apples might look a little wobbly — but that’s exactly the point.

Because sometimes the best pies are the ones that almost tip over.

And in that case … you might need the mop.

This post contains affiliate links. I may earn compensation when you click on the links at no additional cost to you.